3 Unique Dessert Shops on Anna Maria Island

What would a vacation be without something a little sweet? Well, if you are spending your vacation on Anna Maria Island, you’re in luck! This island has some of the best choices for dessert restaurants and places to eat with a variety of themes and treats.

From your morning donut to an afternoon trip for homemade ice cream with your family, there are plenty of attractions on Anna Maria Island that will satisfy whatever food your sweet tooth is craving.

cupcakes on a counter
Photo from Pixabay

Hometown Desserts

When you think of dessert, some of the first things that probably come to mind are cakes, cupcakes, and pies. Hometown Desserts is one of the best dining options on Anna Maria Island offering you exactly that: plenty of traditional desserts and custom cakes.

If you are wondering if Hometown Desserts is worthy of your time, consider the local restaurants around the island. Many of their desserts are provided by Hometown Desserts, meaning that a good portion of the patrons of places to eat on the island enjoy these desserts on a daily basis – even if they don’t visit the bakery itself!

It isn’t just restaurants that can reap the benefits of Hometown Desserts, though. You can order your own custom cakes as well. So, whether you are looking for a snack or a beautiful wedding cake, Hometown Desserts will have what you need.

fresh donuts on display
Photo from Pixabay

Donut Experiment

Nothing is quite as tasty as a donut for breakfast. The only thing that’s better than waking up to a box of donuts, though, is biting into a fresh, custom donut. The Donut Experiment is a donut shop like you’ve never seen before. Instead of coming in and seeing rows of donuts laid out for you, the Donut Experiment makes their donuts for you as you watch.

You don’t have to choose pre-made options off a menu either; the Donut Experiment is an activity to participate in as well. Instead, you and your kids get a chance to create the donut of your dreams!

You start by choosing from one of their cake donuts then add one of their signature icings. After that, you get to add any sort of toppings you want; from candies to snacks and even more. You can get a single donut or even design your own dozen or half-dozen to take home for later!

Tyler’s Homemade Ice Cream

Enjoying Florida’s attractions with your family on a hot day isn’t quite complete without a cold ice cream cone in your hand. However, there isn’t anything much better than that ice cream being a homemade cone of your favorite flavor.

Tyler’s Homemade Ice Cream is one of the best restaurants on the island when it comes to frozen treats. They serve up soft-serve ice cream in a variety of flavors, cones, banana splits, milkshakes, sundaes, floats, and even pints & quarts you can take home and enjoy later.

If you end up visiting this family-owned restaurant, it will easily take you back to when you were a little kid, excited for a delicious treat!