Grabbing pizza on Anna Maria Island should be on your bucket list of things to enjoy when vacationing on Anna Maria Island. We have listed down our top picks of outstanding Anna Maria Island pizza places you must visit. From eating at the restaurant to ordering a pizza to be delivered to your AMI rentals we picked for you, read on to find the best pizza on Anna Maria Island.
Oma’s Pizza & Italian Restaurant
Located in Bradenton Beach at 201 Gulf Dr. N., Oma’s Pizza & Italian Restaurant is an outstanding Anna Maria Island pizza place with a unique take on pizza. Oma’s Pizza & Italian Restaurant is dedicated to the craft of pizza making and all their pizzas are handmade.
The restaurant promises freshness and uniqueness with its offering of 2 types of crusts, namely the Hand-tossed and inch-thick Sicilian. Oma’s Pizza & Italian Restaurant understands that travelers have a taste for good things at odd hours. The restaurant serves such travelers by being open till late at 12 a.m. welcoming all with a late-night craving.
The restaurant also tops its highly beloved and renowned pizza with other delightful Italian dishes. Grace your vacation with Oma’s hero sandwiches and choose from the extensive list of entrees, including Baked Ziti, Chicken Picatta, Veal and Mushrooms, and Grouper Fradiavolo, to mention but a few.
Enjoy the restaurant’s famous Tiramisu as the dessert that seals your memorable experience at Oma’s. Visit the restaurant any time after opening hours at 10 a.m. or make a call via (941) 778-0771 for any inquiries.
The Feast Restaurant
The Feast Restaurant is one of Anna Maria Island restaurants that takes gourmet to a whole new level. Fancy is an understatement when defining Feast Restaurant because guests are required to make a reservation to enjoy the promised luxury Italian treats. The restaurant’s gourmet pizzas are always freshly made using fresh vegetables and tasteful pizza sauce and dough.
The Feast Restaurant also boasts of other masterpiece dishes. Enjoy a taste of fresh steaks, seafood such as Wahoo, Snowy Brown Grouper, Monkfish, Swordfish, and Sheepshead, and salads. The restaurant also offers top-tier cocktails and a wide selection of tasteful wines on their menu.
The Feast Restaurant understands that touring and exploring all the wonders on Anna Maria Island can be tiring, thus offering the option to order your delightful pizza online. For the ultimate experience of Anna Maria Island’s fancy gourmet restaurant, visit the Feast Restaurant at 5406 Marina Drive. Remember to make a reservation at (941) 778-5092.
Vinny’s Italian Kitchen
Vinny’s Italian Kitchen stays true to its name by being an authentic Italy in the heart of Anna Maria Island with the best pizza on Anna Maria Island. Vinny’s has an outstanding menu graced with Italian dishes but its Rustic Thin Crust Pizza always steals the show. For the Italian aesthetic and spirit, all pizzas at Vinny’s are prepared in a wood-burning brick oven to give that authentic Italian vibe.
Choose from the House Pizza made from regular pizza sauce, mozzarella, spices, and extra virgin olive oil or the sassy Queen Margarita made with tomato, spices, pizza sauce, fresh basil, mozzarella, and extra virgin olive oil. If you are a lover of gluten-free food, Vinny’s doesn’t leave you behind and offers gluten-free pizza.
Vinny’s Italian Kitchen also promises an authentic experience with other Italian dishes, Italian pastries from the restaurant’s own bakery, and Artisan Italian Breads, among other splendid dishes. Shop for groceries at Vinny’s on your way out to carry with you to your AMI vacation rental for that late-night snack.
The restaurant is open Monday to Saturday from 11:00 AM – 7:00 PM and stays closed on Sundays. No reservations are needed to enjoy the promised Italian fine dining. Visit Vinny’s at 5337 Gulf Drive or make a call at (941) 896-9754 to make your inquiries.
Pizza Social
At Pizza Social, all pizzas are made from scratch and handmade. The restaurant pours out its heart to hand-make the pizza dough and tomato-based pizza sauce daily. For the thin crust packed with freshness, Pizza Social stretches and tosses its dough by hand, topped with mozzarella cheese before being tossed in an imported Italian oven. The restaurant is open every day except Tuesday from 11 am – 9 pm.
Pizzano’s Pizza
Located at 5318 Marina Drive, Pizzano’s Pizza and Grinderz has both a tasteful history and pizza. The restaurant has an old-school vibe that also filters into its pizzas. Having been in operation for over 30 years across Florida, Pizzano’s Pizza and Grinderz decided to grace Anna Maria Island with fresh and handmade pizzas.
The pizza place is only two blocks from the beach and serves the heavy surfers and tourists after splendid fishing, boating, or wildlife watching on Anna Maria Island. All the dough and pizza sauces are made from scratch to give that traditional pizza experience.
In addition to pizza, the restaurant also provides wings, grinderz, garlic knots, pasta, bread, and desserts. Pizzano’s is operational Monday to Thursday between 10 a.m.-12 a.m.; Friday and Saturday from 10 a.m. to 1 a.m., and Sunday from 11 a.m. to 12 a.m. Visit the restaurant or make a call at 941- 778-3663 to make an order.
Plan Your Next Visit!
Are you ready to find your new favorite restaurants on Anna Maria Island? Browse our selection of rental properties today and start planning your next stay!
Book Your Anna Maria Island Vacation Rental With Beach House Real Estate
Now that you know all the best Anna Maria Island pizza places, allow Beach House Real Estate to find you the perfect Anna Maria Island rentals for your vacation. At Beach House Real Estate, we provide the best and cozy Anna Maria Island vacation rentals ranging from one-bedroom units to 5 bedroom units.
For those thirsty for luxury on their vacation, we offer a wide range of Anna Maria Island rentals with pools and others you can choose from. Book your stay with us for that perfect island retreat you will live to tell.
